McMillen and Wife Steelers Message Board
All time Steeler rankings? - Printable Version

+- McMillen and Wife Steelers Message Board (http://s675307413.onlinehome.us)
+-- Forum: Mac and Wife's Steelers Message Board (http://s675307413.onlinehome.us/forumdisplay.php?fid=1)
+--- Forum: Steelers Talk (http://s675307413.onlinehome.us/forumdisplay.php?fid=2)
+--- Thread: All time Steeler rankings? (/showthread.php?tid=903)



All time Steeler rankings? - Chucktownsteeler - 11-27-2017

Is Ben the #1 Steeler QB of all-time?

Is Bell the #1 Steeler RB of all-time?

Is Brown the #1 Steeler WR of all-time?

Is Boswell the #1 Steeler kicker of all-time?

I have a lot of "B"'s up there and a lot of "yeses"


RE: All time Steeler rankings? - RaynorShyne - 11-27-2017

Is Ben the #1 Steeler QB of all-time?    Tough call.  There's this Bradshaw guy with four rings.

Is Bell the #1 Steeler RB of all-time?  No.  Single season?  Barry Bananas in 1992.  Career?  Franco, baby.  

Is Brown the #1 Steeler WR of all-time?  Not yet - but he'll be there soon

Is Boswell the #1 Steeler kicker of all-time?   No - I'd go Gary Anderson


RE: All time Steeler rankings? - dbsfgyd1 - 11-29-2017

(11-27-2017, 02:58 PM)RaynorShyne Wrote: Is Ben the #1 Steeler QB of all-time?    Tough call.  There's this Bradshaw guy with four rings.

Is Bell the #1 Steeler RB of all-time?  No.  Single season?  Barry Bananas in 1992.  Career?  Franco, baby.  

Is Brown the #1 Steeler WR of all-time?  Not yet - but he'll be there soon

Is Boswell the #1 Steeler kicker of all-time?   No - I'd go Gary Anderson

Too hard to compare different eras. Bradshaw and his 50% completion percentage would likely keep him on the bench today. 

Stalls had a long career, the length of not often seen today. Must have been because the 1st 4 years the Steelers didn’t pass much. 

Franco also had a very long productive career. I like Bell a lot, but his “I’m a need $15 mil” price tag is going to have his butt out of town before too long.